Nobody has said what is making parts of Staunton and Waynesboro smell, and in the absence of an official answer the neighborhood has supplied its own. Since approximately November 10, residents of both municipalities and the Augusta County farmland between them have reported an odor more intense and more geographically extensive than the seasonal smells they recognize, and the explanation offered most often is biosolids, the treated sewage sludge that Virginia farmers spread on cropland after harvest. We examined state, county, municipal and local news sources this week and found no public statement naming a cause.
A neighborhood of amateur investigators
A post in the Staunton VA Facebook group on November 10 drew more than 230 comments, and the thread reads like a field survey conducted by people with no instruments and plenty of motivation. Kimberly Jacobchik, who started the post, grew up in the country and called the smell “absolutely the worst thing I’ve ever smelled.” Debra Blackwell told her, “You must live near expo,” after driving past the day before, and Sherry Boyd found Waynesboro’s air “sickening” that same afternoon.
Longtime residents disagreed about how extraordinary the situation is.
Cassy Painter answered with the distinction that matters most to this story; the area smells every year, she wrote, but has “basically never smelled like this,” which explains why so many residents are discussing it.
Whatever is happening, the community’s collective memory says it differs in intensity and reach from the agricultural odors of autumns past.
Practical remedies arrived within hours, and Amy Van Siclen has been simmering cinnamon sticks, cloves, nutmeg and dried ginger on her stove, and reported that it was “helping... some.” Another commenter recommended switching a car’s ventilation to recirculate. One woman asserted that treated sludge and livestock manure are being spread in Waynesboro, Fishersville and Augusta County this month, a claim she did not source and one we found no record to support or refute.
Jeff Trapani went further than most, locating the Augusta Free Press report on a 2023 application near Route 254 and Brower Road, citing the state regulation that requires advance notice and warning signs, and announcing a plan: “I’ll reach out to Virginia DEQ’s Valley Regional Office.”
His instinct was right.
Treated sludge with a permit
Wastewater treatment facilities separate solid material from the water they purify. When that sludge has been treated to meet state and federal standards, Virginia’s Department of Environmental Quality calls it biosolids, and the material may be applied to cropland as fertilizer under DEQ regulation. That framework comes from a 2023 explainer in Augusta Free Press.
The program carries considerable local history. In October 2023, a contractor spread anaerobically digested Class B biosolids from the North River plant in Mount Crawford on harvested corn fields at a farm near Route 254 and Brower Road, according to DEQ’s account in that report. In April 2024 a sign at the same farm announced another application, and a DEQ spokesperson told the paper that this round used material from the Harrisonburg-Rockingham Regional Sewer Authority plus food-processing residuals from WhiteWave. Both facilities sit in Rockingham County, a circumstance that bears on a question Doug Carpenter raised in the thread: why sludge is not spread “in the city limits where it come from.” At least at that farm, it came from somewhere else.
The mixture varies from one load to the next, depending on which plant produced it and what else was blended in, and that variability complicates any attempt to explain an odor that residents call unprecedented.
What the nose reports
A 2008 expert panel convened by the Commonwealth found that ammonia and reduced sulfur compounds are the most noticeable irritants, usually during application, and that they dilute with distance. The panel added that well-run production and application can prevent odors, that poor handling can create them, and that a bad smell can signal that required treatment standards were not met.
An EPA study, as summarized by the Virginia Biosolids Council, an industry trade group, measured odorants at their highest right after application and found them undetectable afterward. That pattern predicts a smell that peaks as a field is worked and then recedes.
Residents describe a different phenomenon: a smell that has persisted for days and covered miles. Several fields worked in sequence could produce that duration, as could an unusual material, a handling failure, or a source with no connection to agriculture. Only records can sort among those possibilities, because a nose cannot distinguish one source of contamination from another.
Where nuisance ends and risk begins
The federal Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry says most substances behind outdoor odors are “not at levels that can harm your health.” The agency also acknowledges that odor alone can make people ill; headache and nausea are the most common symptoms, and they can appear below irritation levels, driven by the foulness of the odor, past bad experiences with it, worry that it is dangerous, and stress. People with asthma, allergies, migraines or chronic lung conditions may react more strongly, and the agency advises staying indoors on high-odor days, leaving the area for a few hours when possible, and seeing a doctor about symptoms.
Virginia’s legislative auditors reached a similar reading in 2017. Their review of land application found that odors can cause eye and throat irritation, headaches and nausea, and that the overall health risk is low under state rules, a conclusion supported by health department reviews in 2007 and 2014 that found no immediate public health concerns. The report also identified a gap in the evidence, namely the absence of an authoritative study of illness among people who live near spread fields. It noted that Class B biosolids carry more pathogens than Class A, with aerosolized viruses such as norovirus the main worry for downwind neighbors during application, and it observed that Virginia did not then require pathogen testing of Class B material.
The contaminant with no scent
Ammonia and sulfur compounds belong to a different chemical family from PFAS, the “forever chemicals,” so the intensity of an odor reveals little about which PFAS a batch carries. The PFAS question concerns contamination of soil, groundwater, crops and livestock over years and decades, and it has elevated biosolids from an agricultural footnote into a legislative controversy.
EPA’s January 2025 draft risk assessment found that people who live on or near land receiving biosolids with PFOA or PFOS, or who rely mainly on food and water from that land, can face risks above EPA’s thresholds in some scenarios. The agency also said its analysis does not suggest the general food supply is affected. Maine illustrates how a severe case unfolds: a dairy farmer in Arundel was forced to euthanize a contaminated herd, and the state banned spreading biosolids on farmland in 2022.
Virginia has lagged in laboratory testing. Federal rules cover certain heavy metals and pathogens but not PFAS, and the Augusta and Rockbridge Alliance, a conservation group, counted 417 locations in the two counties that received biosolids between 2007 and 2022, with more than 6,500 spreading events. Clark Lester wrote in the thread that “They need to pass a law against this!” Virginia has passed one this year, though it targets PFAS testing, and the summaries we reviewed do not mention odor. Governor Spanberger signed HB 1443, which bars land application of sludge above 50 parts per billion of PFOA or PFOS and sets lighter requirements below that, with none under 25. The testing requirement begins January 1, 2027, monthly at first, which means anything spread this November predates it.
The Lexington page’s follow-up post adds that treatment does not remove pharmaceuticals, radioactive material or chemotherapy drugs. EPA’s national surveys have catalogued pharmaceuticals, steroids and hormones in sewage sludge, and Washington State health officials found small amounts of radioactive material from natural, fallout and medical sources in sludge they sampled in the 1990s. We found no Virginia test results for either category and no source on chemotherapy drugs in sludge, so those claims remain unverified for this region.
Cheap fertilizer in an expensive year
Kristi Sprouse Saunders asked in the thread whether growers are using a different fertilizer because supplies once moved through the Middle East’s shipping lanes. Commodity prices lend the question considerable credibility. After shipping through the Strait of Hormuz was disrupted, urea more than doubled to about $850 a metric ton in April, according to the World Trade Organization, then fell to near $400 by July, and phosphate rose 25% and stayed elevated through August.
Biosolids cost farmers nothing, and the Virginia Biosolids Council’s own newsletter has described them as provided free, with a value of $250 to $350 an acre against commercial fertilizer, a 2012 industry figure, and the Augusta Free Press explainer reports that the generator pays a $7.50 per dry ton fee that funds DEQ and local monitoring. The economic incentive is plausible, but we found no data showing whether applications in Augusta County rose this fall.
Following the notices
Virginia’s rules leave a paper trail. Permit holders must notify DEQ and the local government at least 14 days before application starts, and again within 24 hours before application or delivery begins, naming the biosolids source, under state regulation 9VAC25-32-515. Signs must be posted at least five business days before delivery and remain at least 30 days after the work concludes, and each sign identifies the permit holder and provides a telephone number for complaints. A permit holder must begin investigating a complaint within 24 hours, and a locality that receives one must forward it to DEQ and the permit holder within the same period.
Augusta County falls under the jurisdiction of DEQ’s Valley Regional Office in Harrisonburg, reachable at 540-574-7800 from 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. on weekdays. A resident may inquire whether any land application occurred near a given address since November 1, and which permit holder and treatment facility were involved. Providing the date and location of the odor creates an official record. State rules require odor control plans and let DEQ add permit conditions, but the auditors found they do not bar material solely because it smells offensive.
Anyone experiencing symptoms should consult a physician, and the odor may yet prove to have an ordinary explanation unrelated to sludge. DEQ and Augusta County hold the notices that would show whether fields near Staunton and Waynesboro received it this month, and until those records are public, the cause stays unconfirmed.



