When this newsletter first covered Mary Baldwin University’s accreditation probation in late June, the immediate facts were these: on June 26, 2026, SACSCOC placed the university on Probation for Good Cause for failing Standard 13.3, the accreditor’s financial responsibility standard, and gave it twelve months to fix the problem. Six weeks later, the picture has filled in considerably, and most of what’s filled in concerns who is now actually in charge of the fix.
A Fourth President Since 2023
Gary Daynes is Mary Baldwin’s twelfth president, and he is the third person to hold the job in roughly the past year alone. The churn at the top explains a good deal about how the university arrived at probation in the first place. Pamela R. Fox led the school for twenty years before stepping down in 2023. Her successor, Jeffrey Stein, arrived from Elon University and lasted barely two years before resigning in August 2025, a matter of weeks into the academic year. Vice president Todd Telemeco stepped in, then announced in January that he too would step down, citing family and personal reasons. It was Telemeco who issued the university’s public comment on the day the probation news broke, before handing the job to Daynes on July 1.
Daynes arrives with a résumé built for exactly this problem. He comes from Salem Academy and College in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, where he served as interim president, and before that spent nearly a decade as provost and vice president for academic affairs at Barton College. He and his wife Kristine co-founded Back Porch Consulting, through which he has advised more than twenty independent colleges on strategy, program design, and financial sustainability. His title at Mary Baldwin is not just interim president. It’s interim president and chief transformation officer, a title that says plainly what the trustees hired him to do. The board approved him for a two-year term.
What Probation Actually Touches
Probation status is not confined to the Staunton campus. It applies to every program, every branch campus, every off-campus site, and MBU’s distance learning programs, which means the Murphy Deming College of Health Sciences campus in Fishersville and MBU Online carry the same monitoring status as the main campus.
The path back to full standing has a defined shape. Mary Baldwin will submit a monitoring report to SACSCOC in spring 2027, followed by a site visit from a SACSCOC special committee to evaluate progress in person. When the board reconvenes in June 2027, it has three options on the table: release the university from probation outright, continue the probation with a further monitoring report and another special committee review, or remove the university from membership entirely for failing to comply with accreditation standards. The middle option, in practice, would mean another year of exactly the uncertainty the university is living through now.
How Students Are Reading It
For students, the university’s messaging has been consistent: nothing about enrollment, degree validity, or financial aid access changes during probation. The emotional experience on the ground looks different than the FAQ language suggests. Lillian Jenkins, a junior who transferred to Mary Baldwin, told WHSV she received the probation notice by email while at work and described it as frightening, despite already knowing the school had financial troubles. She said some classmates began discussing transfer options after reading the notice. Jenkins herself plans to finish her degree before the June 2027 review, but her stated worry wasn’t for herself. It was for newer students and those already struggling financially, and what happens to their credits if accreditation is ultimately lost.
University spokesperson Liesel Nowak has framed the moment as one of resolve rather than crisis, telling the Staunton News Leader that the institution enters this period with committed leadership, a clear charge, and confidence in the path forward. Telemeco, in his final public comments as president, pointed to specific fiscal year 2026 actions the university had already taken: tighter controls on spending, a reorganization following workforce reductions, intensified fundraising, and investment in new revenue-generating programs. He said the university intended to accelerate that work into fiscal year 2027, language that is now Daynes’s inheritance rather than Telemeco’s promise.
Why This Still Matters Beyond Frederick Street
Mary Baldwin enrolls nearly 1,800 undergraduate and graduate students across its Staunton campus, its Fishersville health sciences campus, and its online programs, and it remains one of the larger employers and cultural institutions in this city. The Murphy Deming campus specifically trains nurses, physical therapists, and physician assistants who go on to staff healthcare systems across the Shenandoah Valley. A downgrade in accreditation status would not stay contained to a university newsletter. It would ripple into regional healthcare staffing, into downtown Staunton’s economy, and into the plans of nearly two thousand students currently mid-degree.
Ten months remain before the SACSCOC board reconvenes. The Stauntonian will keep tracking what Daynes’s administration does with them.




